40 U.S. Government Lies, Coverups & Abuses
The United States Government is no stranger to Lies, Coverups & Abuses. Here is a list of just 40 well-known examples.
We love our country, but we hate our government…and for good reason. The government of the United States is one of the most lying and corrupt governments on earth. We take comfort in a false belief that the things our government does is for our protection. After all, that’s why the government exists. But the truth is that there is no technology that our government possesses, that it will not eventually use on its own people.
Below is a summary, in no particular order, of 40 times our government has lied or covered up it’s own abuses against citizens or humanity … and that’s not even including the obvious one of the invention of nuclear weapons.
1. CIA Mind Control Program – MKULTRA – The CIA illegally administered drugs such as LSD to thousands of people without their knowledge and often ran experiments on them. Many people died and their families would never know how/why. The agency destroyed all files in 1973 so we will never know the full extent of the program or who was involved. Nobody was ever prosecuted or fired for the illegal destruction of files.
2. My Lai Massacre – American soldiers from the 1st Battalion, 20th Infantry; 4th Battalion, 3rd Infantry; massacred as many as 500 Vietnamese civilians on March 16, 1968. Before murdering them, some women as young as 12 were gang raped. The government covered it up until they were busted by journalists in late 1969. Only 26 soldiers were charged … but only one was convicted on 22 counts. That man, Lieutenant William Calley Jr., a platoon leader, served 3 1/2 years under house arrest. His sentence was commuted by President Richard Nixon.
3. Republican President Eisenhower authorized the CIA plot to kill Cuban citizens (communists) and Fidel Castro, as well as foment a rebellion in a program called Operation Mongoose in 1960.
4. In the 1920’s during prohibition, the Government forced companies that manufacture alcohol used for cleaners & solvents to include poison in the mixtures to stop people from distilling it for drinking. Over 10,000 people died as a result.
5. Area 51 Environmental Catastrophe. It’s not just about aliens. The U.S. Government denied the existence of the military base, known as Area 51 near Groom Lake in Nevada, from 1955 until 2013. The government would burn toxic materials on the base leading to dozens of military personnel with health problems, including cancer. But because the base didn’t officially exist, the service members had no recourse. The government just let them die without taking any responsibility. In 1993, Democrat President Bill Clinton signed an executive order that exempts Area 51 from all environmental laws, furthering the injustice that future service members will face.
6. Under the direction of Attorney General Janet Reno, the FBI murdered 80 people; men, women & children, in an attack on a church compound in Waco, TX in 1993. With little to no evidence of a minor weapons charge, the FBI led a misinformation campaign against a church leader, David Koresh, in order to gain public support for a raid on the compound. They burned the people alive inside the building.
7. The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment. From 1930’s to the 1970’s, the U.S. Public Health Service conducted experiments on unwitting poor, black citizens in order to study the effects and progression of untreated syphilis. The government lied to them and promised them free medical care but instead gave them syphilis in order to monitor the effects.
8. Cigarettes are good for you. All the way into the 1960’s, tobacco companies bought and paid for politicians who created policies to encourage smoking, even lying to the Public by getting doctors to endorse the products as an aid to increase lung capacity. This all occurred while it was already known of the dangers. While we blame the tobacco companies, the Government was just as much involved in the deception.
9. CIA torture. Following 9/11, the CIA engaged in “enhanced interrogation” (ie: Torture) with suspected “terrorists”. They manipulated the definition of “terrorists” to include any person who might have the information needed to conduct an investigation into a terrorist plot. The details of the CIA operation were withheld from President Bush for 4 years.
10. DARPA hacks the weather for war. In 1993, the government built a facility in Gakona, Alaska known as HAARP (High-Frequency Active Auroral Research Program) in order to heat the ionosphere and manipulate the weather to enhance military objectives of war. Many now believe that it may be partly responsible for global warming and is used to feed the narrative for green initiatives.
11. In 1955, The FBI stalked Martin Luther King Jr. because of his involvement with the Montgomery bus boycott. They accused him of being a communist without any evidence. They assigned undercover operatives to infiltrate his inner circle and try to convince him to kill himself. King was just the highest-ranking member of the government’s widespread illegal tracking of “black activists”.
12. The Pentagon Papers. The DOD commissioned a study of the Vietnam War and the United States’ involvement from 1945 to 1967. It detailed how the government manipulated the public through the media into supporting the Vietnam War and how it lied not only to the public but to Congress. When journalist Daniel Ellsberg published the story, he was rewarded with criminal charges of conspiracy, espionage, and theft of government property.
13. “The Nayirah Lie” of George HW Bush. Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait in 1990 and Bush Sr. was looking for a way to justify a war. Kuwait is a non-NATO ally that we had no duty to defend or protect … unless we wanted to keep our greedy hands on their oil. Bush Sr. trotted out a 15-year-old girl named “Nayirah” who spun a horrific tale of Iraqi soldiers bursting into a hospital in Kuwait and removing babies from their incubators, to leave them dying on the floor. But it was all a lie. Nayirah was the daughter of Kuwait’s ambassador to the U.S. and was coached into a false story to gain sympathy for Bush’s war. In the end, it was Bush Sr. that killed babies when the U.S. bombing knocked out power to hospitals and those babies who were on ventilation died.
14. Weapons of Mass Destruction. Following 9/11, the government needed a scapegoat. Even though Saddam Hussein had nothing to do with 9/11, they perpetuated a lie that he had weapons of mass destruction and was likely to use them against U.S. Allies. This gave President George Bush Jr. the excuse needed to invade Iraq. Aside from a few, inoperative gas projectiles, no “mass destruction” devices were ever found…. Bush made up the whole thing to justify an invasion.
15. Roswell Aliens, Not Aliens. In 1947, a crash of an alien spacecraft allegedly occurred in Roswell, NM. The Roswell Army Air Field reported in a press release that they recovered a “flying disk”. Within hours the story was recanted and the government proclaimed it was only a weather balloon. In 1994, the military admitted that they deliberately lied to the public and that the “weather balloon” was actually a top-secret military surveillance balloon code-named, Project Mogul. Once a liar, always a liar. There is no reason to trust anything they tell the public about this.
16. The USS Scorpion. In 1968 the U.S. Navy submarine USS Scorpion went missing in the Atlantic. The government lied to the public that the ship was lost due to an unexplained failure. 99 crewmen died. In 2010 it was revealed that the ship was likely destroyed by a Soviet submarine and that the government had known this since July of 1968 when the wreckage was found.
17. Agent Orange, Vietnam. More lies about Vietnam. The government used a chemical agent “herbicide” to deforest areas of Vietnam between 1962 & 1971. They dropped more than 19 million gallons, covering not only forests but people and animals. The government denied the cancerous effects of the material until 1983, when a settlement was reached. For their service and sacrifice, veterans were given approximately $3800 each.
18. Freedom of the press. The Nixon administration illegally wiretapped journalists put them on enemies lists and audited their tax returns. They censored news stations by threatening to revoke their broadcasting licenses. Seems oddly familiar with events today.
19. Democrat President Woodrow Wilson signed the “espionage act” which he used to imprison journalists and shut down newspapers that disagreed with his policies. It worked so well in stifling speech that the government continues to use that act to this day. Seems oddly familiar with events today.
20. Watergate. Young people may not be familiar with President Richard Nixon and “Watergate”. In 1972, Nixon authorized the break-in of the Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Washington, D.C., Watergate Office Building to steal documents and tap phone lines. Witnesses testified against Nixon in Senate hearings. Ultimately, the coverup was worse than the crime and Nixon was forced to resign from office.
21. Obamacare. In an effort to push a socialist-style, single-payer health care system down the throat of the American people, President Barak (Barry) Hussein Obama (Soetoro) lied to the American people over and over about how they would be able to keep their doctor. Except, most wouldn’t be able to and Obama knew it at the time. You can’t keep a doctor that is either out of business or is not part of the “approved” system.
22. Nord Stream 2. Pulitzer prize journalist Seymour Hersh reveals that Joe Biden ordered the destruction of the Nord Stream 2 pipeline under the Baltic Sea in September 2022. Biden all as much admitted his intent to do so if Russia invaded Ukraine … which they did, just 4 months later. Backing up Biden, Pentagon spokesman Marine Corps Lt. Col. Garron J. Garn told The Post “The United States was not involved in the Nord Stream explosion.” The report from Hersh reveals that they ALL lied to the American public because blowing up a vital supply line to a NATO ally could break up the coalition… not to mention it would open up U.S. targets to Russia as justifiable retaliation … causing WWIII.
23. PRISM. Edward Snowden, a CIA data analyst blew the whistle to reveal that the NSA had a secret program called PRISM, which is used to spy on U.S. Citizens’ email, internet activity, phone calls, and more. For his trouble, he has been living in exile in Russia while not one person in our government has been held accountable for their illegal & unconstitutional activity. Nobody, not even President Trump, has put a stop to this policy. The program marches on to this very day with the government spying on Americans for no legitimate reason.
24. The assassination of President John F. Kennedy. Nobody of sound mind believes that Lee Harvey Oswald killed JFK in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963 … or at least nobody believes that he did it alone. Witnesses testified to hearing shots from multiple locations. A “magic bullet” theory had to be concocted to explain the multiple wounds from the limited number of shots fired by Oswald’s location. Classified documents were supposed to be released in 1992 but every President since that time has extended the deadline. The last President to extend the deadline was Joe Biden who pushed it one last time to December 15, 2022 … Following that deadline, the national archives released 13,000 worthless documents. Keeping the juicy, top-secret stuff that reveals the truth, hidden from the public…probably forever.
25. Monica Lewinsky was hired as an intern for President Bill Clinton. Clinton took advantage of her naivete and engaged in oral sex (at least) with her in the oval office. He lied to the American People, as well as his wife, about the affair and was impeached. His famous line, “I did not have sex with that woman, Mrs. Lewinsky” rings in infamy and taught us how politicians can twist language… ie: “sex” is only “intercourse” and not “oral” … if that is what you believe when you give sworn testimony.
26. The “Iran-Contra Affair” was a secret U.S. arms deal that traded U.S. missiles and other arms to free some Americans held hostage by terrorists in Lebanon but also used funds from the arms deal to support armed conflict in Nicaragua. The scandal might have brought down President Ronald Reagan if not for the loyalty of Oliver North … who took the brunt of the scandal on behalf of the President.
27. The “Fast and Furious” gun-running scandal was headed by Attorney General Eric Holder, under the direction of President Obama in 2009. Fast and Furious was a Justice Department program that allowed government-owned assault weapons to be sold to Mexican drug cartels, allegedly as a way to track them. But internal documents later revealed the real goal was to gin up a crisis requiring a crackdown on guns in America. Fast and Furious was merely a pretext for imposing stricter gun laws.
28. The Man-Made Global Warming Lie. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has been busted in tampering with temperature statistics by lowering previously measured temperatures to show cooler weather in the past and raising more recent temperatures to show warming in the recent present. This “green agenda” is a trillion-dollar gravy train that nobody wants to stop. But it’s not just about money, it’s also about control … control over your life. Because you can’t be trusted with making decisions for yourself.
29. The nuclear agreement with Iran by President Barak (Barry) Hussein Obama (Soetoro) sold to Congress & the American public permits Iran to possess nuclear weapons in about ten years (ie: 2026). The justification was that Capitalism had made the new Iranian government more moderate and proposed that the Iranians deserve to have Nuclear power (whilst it is being blacklisted in our own country). Ben Rhodes, a National Security Adviser in the Obama administration, bragged about the lies and stated that the intelligence community knew it was a lie all along.
30. 3 weeks to flatten the curve. “Flattening the curve” was a public health strategy to slow down the spread of the SARS-CoV-2 virus during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. The People were told that if we would all just mask up and stay home for 3 weeks, we would stamp out the virus… or at least enable our medical centers to keep up. It was all a lie to calm people with the bonus of taking away civil liberties. The lockdowns would last for 2-3 years, crushed many middle-class families, and shuttered tens of thousands of small businesses…while big business chains were barely affected.
31. “Operation warp speed” was a partnership between the Government and pharmaceutical companies to accelerate the development of a COVID-19 vaccine by January 2021. To accomplish this, President Donald Trump allowed himself to be duped by the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), Anthony Fauci, into believing that tens of millions of people would die from the virus unless he (Trump) allows people to be injected with an experimental biological agent.
The began a campaign to deceive the public by redefining a “vaccine” to include the experimental biological agent. Not only did the “vaccine” not stop the spread, but it didn’t prevent infection either. In fact, it has massive side effects, including death… which the government refused to let people know about and continues to cover up to this day. Hundreds of thousands of people have died from the “vaccine” already and yet mandates for its continued use continue in some places.
32. The Russian Collusion Hoax. The Democrat National Committee (DNC) conspired, with funding from Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton to slander and frame President Donald Trump with a conspiracy to steal the 2016 election with the help of the Russians. Many outlandish claims were made which have all been revealed to be false. Yet the media, in actual collusion with the DNC and the Biden administration, refuse to cover or investigate the truth.
33. Don’t get droned. “Anwar al-Awlaki” was targeted for assassination by the CIA for his suspected involvement in Al-Qaeda. He was considered “too dangerous” due to his lecturing and publications as an American-Yemeni imam (religious leader) and some people even referred to him as the “Bin Laden of the Internet.” On September 30, 2011, President Obama ordered his assassination and the CIA fired multiple missiles at his vehicle in Yemen, killing him and everybody else in the vehicle. While it is probably likely that Anwar al-Awlaki was indeed a terrorist, he was also an American citizen who was deprived of his right to due process and a trial by jury. He could have been captured, as many terrorists were, but instead, he was intentionally murdered by a President of the United States in order to send a message.
34. Ruby Ridge. In 1992 Randy Weaver was a doomsday prepper and a self-professed white separatist. He fled to his Ruby Ridge, Idaho home after failing to appear in court on ATF charges he received when he sold two sawed-off shotguns to an ATF agent. When U.S. Marshals and the FBI confronted his family outside his property on August 21, 1992 a brief gun battle ensued. Marshals shot Weaver’s dog, then shot Weaver’s 14-year-old son in the back as he ran away, killing him. Weaver’s friend, Kevin Harris then shot and killed a federal marshal. A standoff ensued and the next day an FBI sniper killed Weaver’s unarmed wife while she was holding her 10-month-old daughter. Weaver was wounded as well as a friend. Weaver surrendered two weeks later.
The jury acquitted Weaver of all charges except two, one of which the judge set aside. He was found guilty of one count, failure to appear, for which he was fined $10,000 and sentenced to 18 months in prison. He was credited with time served plus an additional three months, and he was then released. Kevin Harris was acquitted of all criminal charges.
In August 1995, the US government avoided trial on a civil lawsuit filed by the Weavers by awarding the three surviving daughters $1,000,000 each, and Randy Weaver $100,000 over the deaths of Sammy and Vicki Weaver.
No FBI agent or Marshal was ever held accountable for the murders of Weaver’s wife, son or dog.
35. “Project Serpo” was an alleged top-secret alien exchange program between the United States government and an alien planet called, “Serpo” which is located in the Zeta Reticuli star system.
In reality, Project Serpo was a disinformation campaign by United States Air Force Sergeant Richard C. Doty at the direction of the D.O.J. Office of Special Investigations (O.S.I.). The purpose of the campaign was to infiltrate the UFO circuit and slowly feed an ever-increasing absurd story in order to discredit discussions about alien civilizations and visitation. The real questions are, “Why did the government lie?” and “Why did the government feel the need to lie?” … to the American people about this issue.
36. “Stuxnet” was the world’s most sophisticated, mutating, computer virus ever created, sometime between 2005-2010. Developed by the NSA & Mossad (Israel Intelligence) under a program called “Operation Olympic Games”, this self-replicating virus was designed to infect a specific component in Iran’s uranium enrichment facility to cause them to self-destruct. But to get the virus into the air-gapped computer system, they literally and intentionally infected hundreds of millions of computers all over the world, probably even your own home computer, knowing that eventually it would affect a single USB flash drive and be inserted into the Iranians centrifuge system.
It cannot be understated … these governments were literally willing to infect the entire world to ensure that the virus would get into a single USB drive. And now this technology is being used by every nation-state in the world to attack the infrastructure of every other nation.
37. “Operation Northwoods” in 1962 was a false flag operation proposed by the U.S. Military to shoot down American planes and to bomb U.S. bases & cities (ie: Kill Americans) to create the illusion that the United States was under attack by Cuba and thus create a reason for a U.S. invasion. Fortunately, President Kennedy rejected the plan … of course, things didn’t work out too well for him.
38. On January 16, 1893, armed naval forces of the United States led a coup d’état to oust Queen Lili’uokalani of Hawaii. The queen surrendered under protest in order to avoid bloodshed. In 1898 the island territory was officially annexed as a U.S. Territory. Hawaii finally became the 50th State in 1959. The United States officially apologized to native Hawaiians in 1993…but offered no reparations.
39. Entrapment. FBI manipulates, entraps, and then arrests 4 individuals in a plot to kidnap Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer in October 2020. Two of the four were acquitted and the other two defendants ended up in a mistrial. Court records show that the FBI targeted the “militia group” (ie: an organized group of citizens upset with the Governor’s actions regarding COVID). The FBI infiltrated the group with no less than 4 federal agents who manipulated and radicalized the group into planning to kidnap the Governor. The group never actualized the plan. When it became clear that they were not going to follow through, the FBI arrested them on “conspiracy” instead.
40. A “Family Planning Program” was implemented in the 1970s in some African countries by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) and the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) to curb the “problem” of African birth rates. Under the guise of “vaccines”, people were given high doses of Depo-Provera without their knowledge in order to cause permanent infertility. Bill Gates, the founder of Microsoft, funded the operation through the “Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation”.
These are just 40 of the most well-known lies & abuses that the United States Government has perpetrated upon the American People and the world. Our founding fathers did the best job they could in the creation of our governmental system, but they can only go so far. Mankind has a natural proclivity to corruption and susceptibility to evil. We must never lose sight of that and never get so lost in our own patriotism that we shut our eyes to our own government’s abuses.
Fate, TX
Exposed: City of Fate Withholds Documents from Disclosure Without Permission From Attorney General
Ethics Investigation Raises New Questions About Fate’s Response to Open Records Request
Fate, TX — An ethics investigation into former Fate City Councilwoman Codi Chinn has uncovered evidence suggesting the City of Fate possessed at least one employee complaint against former Department of Public Safety Chief Lyle Lombard that it never disclosed in response to an Open Records Request submitted by Pipkins Reports.
The newly released investigative report also raises additional questions about whether City Manager Michael Kovacs fully described his receipt of employee complaint letters during his interview with the City’s outside investigator.
The documents establish the following timeline.
On November 25, 2025, Pipkins Reports submitted a Texas Public Information Act request seeking four categories of records related to Chief Lombard’s employment. Item No. 3 requested:
“Copy of any written complaints against Chief Lombard within the last 12 months prior to termination.”
On December 11, 2025, the City responded by producing Chief Lombard’s performance evaluations, termination documents, and the investigation initiated by City Manager Michael Kovacs. However, the city produced no employee complaint letters.
Because no complaint letters were produced, Pipkins Reports immediately contacted the City for clarification. The follow-up specifically noted that an anonymous employee complaint concerning Lombard had already become publicly known and requested that letter, along with any other anonymous or signed complaints concerning the former chief.
On December 16th, after Pipkins Reports challenged the City’s original response, Associate Attorney Paige Goins of Messer Fort acknowledged that one document—the anonymous letter already known to exist—had been inadvertently omitted and she sent that document to Pipkins Reports.
Then, on December 18, the City supplemented its response again by producing awards and commendations received by Lombard.
At the time, Pipkins Reports did not pursue the matter further. New information obtained through a subsequent ethics investigation has now renewed serious questions about whether the City’s response complied with the Texas Public Information Act.
Under the Texas Public Information Act, governmental bodies generally must either promptly produce responsive public records or seek a ruling from the Texas Attorney General if they believe the requested information falls within an exception to disclosure. If a governmental body fails to timely request an Attorney General ruling, the requested information is generally presumed to be public unless a compelling reason exists to withhold it. See Texas Government Code §§ 552.221, 552.301, and 552.302.
In this case, the City did not seek an Attorney General ruling authorizing its withholding of any documents.
Ethics Investigation Reveals New Information
Seven months later, in July of 2026, an unrelated ethics investigation would reveal information that casts new light on the City’s response.
The investigation originated from an ethics complaint filed by Fate resident Darcy Gildon, who alleged former Councilwoman Codi Chinn improperly involved herself in personnel matters by directing city employees to prepare written complaints concerning Chief Lombard.
Attorney Laura Mueller of Baker Robertson & O’Brien ultimately concluded that Chinn violated Section 2-309(10) of the city’s Code of Ethics by directing employees to provide information to her in writing. Pipkins Reports reported on that story … here.
More significant for purposes of this investigation, however, were the interviews conducted with the individuals involved.
According to the investigative report, Chinn told investigators that city employees approached her seeking assistance. She stated that she instructed them to put their concerns in writing so they could be presented to the City Council. Instead, according to her interview, the employees compiled a letter addressed to the entire City Council, after which she instructed them to deliver the letter to City Manager Michael Kovacs.
The investigative report summarizes Kovacs’ interview as follows:
“In my interview with Mr. Kovacs, we discussed his conversations with then Councilmember Chinn and the employees. Mr. Kovacs stated that he received the letter outlining the employee issues directly from an officer, but with the understanding that the information was given to him at the direction of Ms. Chinn. Mr. Kovacs also stated that Ms. Chinn kept him informed of the conversations she was having with the employees, but that he warned her against such communications.”
The report, however, does not discuss the original anonymous complaint letter that Pipkins Reports previously reported had been delivered to Kovacs through Councilwoman Chinn.
Taken together, the report’s statements—and its omissions—appear to indicate that Kovacs possessed at least two written employee complaints that would have been responsive to Pipkins Reports’ November 2025 Public Information Act request.
Two Letters, One Unanswered Question
Pipkins Reports has independently obtained copies of both complaint letters from sources outside City Hall. One anonymous letter begins with the words, “To Whom It May Concern.” The second letter is addressed to the entire City Council and was reportedly transmitted through Councilwoman Chinn.
Their existence, however, does not resolve whether the City complied with the Texas Public Information Act. The central question is whether the City properly disclosed responsive records in response to a lawful request.
As of this publication, the City still has not disclosed the separate complaint letter that Kovacs later acknowledged receiving directly from a police officer. By his own admission, City Manager Michael Kovacs is the person responsible for the dissemination of records per State Law, and therefore he is the person who should be held accountable.
If Kovacs’ statement to investigators is accurate, that second complaint letter would have existed when the City’s response to the November 2025 Public Information Act request was prepared.
A New Public Information Request
In light of the newly disclosed information, Pipkins Reports has submitted another Texas Public Information Act request seeking all written complaints concerning Chief Lombard, including the complaint letter Kovacs acknowledged receiving from an officer, the complaint letter transmitted through Councilwoman Chinn, and any additional written complaints in the City’s possession.
The request states, in part:
“On 11/25/2025, as part of Open Records Request #R001735-112525, I requested ‘Copy of any written complaints against Chief Lombard within the last 12 months prior to termination.’ The City failed to provide any responsive documents, even though it was publicly known that at least one anonymous complaint letter existed.
During the ethics investigation conducted by Baker Robertson & O’Brien, Michael Kovacs stated that he received a complaint letter from a police officer. This admission indicates the City possessed an additional responsive document that was not disclosed.
The City did not seek an Attorney General ruling authorizing the withholding of either complaint letter. This request seeks both documents, together with any additional written complaints concerning Chief Lombard.”
Whether the City ultimately produces the records—or explains why they were not disclosed nearly eight months ago—may determine whether this story ends as an administrative oversight or raises more significant questions regarding the City’s compliance with the Texas Public Information Act.
This remains an ongoing investigation. Pipkins Reports will continue to report on developments as additional records become available.
Fate Council Dropped Case Before Reviewing
Fate, TX — An ethics investigation commissioned by the City of Fate concluded that former Councilwoman Codi Chinn violated the City’s Code of Ethics before the City Council voted earlier this month to discontinue the matter, according to documents obtained by Pipkins Reports through an Open Records Request.
The report, prepared by attorney Laura Mueller of the law firm Baker, Robertson & O’Brien, found that the allegation against Chinn was “substantiated, but with mitigating factors.”
The Executive Summary states:
“After investigation, my determination is that allegation of a violation of the Ethics Code is substantiated, but with mitigating factors.”
The report concludes that Chinn violated Section 2-309(10) of the City’s Code of Ethics after directing City employees to provide their concerns to her in writing.
“After reviewing the Charter, the Code of Ethics, and reviewing all of the evidence, my conclusion is that Ms. Chinn violated Section 2-309(10) of the Code of Ethics when she directed employees to provide information to her in writing.”
Mueller also concluded that mitigating circumstances should be considered because Chinn immediately informed City Manager Michael Kovacs about the employee concerns and because the employees ultimately submitted their written complaints directly to the City.
Council Ends Investigation
The ethics complaint summary report was scheduled to appear on the July 6 City Council agenda for executive session discussion.
Instead of going into Executive Session, the Council waived deliberative privilege and discussed the matter in open session where they ultimately voted to discontinue the ethics proceedings and drop the matter, before being presented with the findings from Mueller.
The Council did not impose any sanction against Chinn.
The following day, Pipkins Reports requested a copy of the complaint and the investigative report, and received it through an Open Records Request.
Investigation Details
According to the report, investigators interviewed Chinn, Councilman Mark Harper, City Manager Michael Kovacs, and other witnesses.
Regarding the allegations, Mueller wrote:
“In my interview with Ms. Chinn and Mr. Harper, we discussed the allegation. I questioned Ms. Chinn about her conversations with city employees and with Mr. Kovacs.”
According to the report, Chinn stated that city employees approached her seeking assistance and that she intended to present their concerns to the City Manager after compiling the information.
However, the report states that employees instead prepared a letter addressed to the City Council. Chinn then instructed them to provide the letter directly to the City Manager.
The report also summarizes Kovacs’ account of the events.
“Mr. Kovacs stated that he received the letter outlining the employee issues directly from an officer, but with the understanding that the information was given to him at the direction of Ms. Chinn.”
Previously, it was reported that Chinn provided a copy of an, “anonymous letter”, that she claims was provided by DPS officers to her. Chinn further states that she sent the letter to Michael Kovacs … who then forwarded it on to the rest of the Council. This report also states that Kovacs told investigators he had warned Chinn against communicating with employees in that manner.
Pipkins Reports continues to investigate this aspect of the situation … as the conditions shed new light on the events that have transpired with regard to the termination of DPS Chief Lyle Lombard.
Meanwhile, the city council’s decision effectively ended the ethics proceeding against Chinn without imposing any sanction or issuing any formal determination of its own regarding the investigator’s findings. While the Council possessed the authority to discontinue the matter, the decision also brought the ethics process to a close despite an independent investigation concluding that a violation of the City’s Code of Ethics had occurred.
For the complainant, Darcy Gildon, the Council’s action marked the end of a process that resulted in no public accountability beyond the release of the investigative report which Pipkins Reports has now provided.
Chinn and Billings Bash Senator Bob Hall
Fate, TX – The political firestorm over secret recordings inside Fate City Hall just took a sharp and deeply ironic turn. Pipkins Reports has obtained an audio recording that appears to show former Fate City Councilwoman Codi Chinn secretly recording a private telephone conversation with former Mayor David Billings, despite her later public criticism of the practice.
The recording, verified through multiple sources familiar with the matter, predates the recent controversy involving Mayor Andrew Greenberg‘s recorded conversation with Chinn and Councilman Mark Hatley‘s recording of a discussion with City Manager Michael Kovacs. The discovery raises uncomfortable questions about consistency, credibility, and whether Chinn’s outrage over recorded conversations has been driven more by politics, than principle.
Pipkins Reports received a copy of a 32-minute audio recording from an anonymous source who said it originated from a recording obtained through an Open Records Request submitted to the City of Fate.
Pipkins Reports has reviewed documentation related to that request and separately confirmed the recording’s authenticity through sources with knowledge of the file maintained by the city.
Much of the conversation centers around mundane talk about MUD districts. Pipkins Reports has edited the recording to a 2-minute, 47-second excerpt focusing on the discussion involving Texas Sen. Bob Hall because it is directly relevant to matters of public interest.
During the conversation, Chinn expresses frustration with Hall’s reluctance to support legislation to strengthen child protection in schools. Stating that he is, “not interested in having that conversation.” She continues, “He is interested in getting people all riled up, but when it comes time to actually do the work, and his job, he’s nowhere to be found.“
Billings echoes that frustration, and opines how he says Bob Hall, “fights dirty“, and how he has voted against cities 9 times. The conversation paints a picture of two local political figures who believe the longtime senator was not sufficiently responsive to their legislative priorities.
The policy disagreements themselves are not especially unusual. Elected officials often criticize one another behind closed doors. What makes this recording different is the hypocrisy of Chinn, stirring up outrage about “secret recordings” when she herself has been a proponent.
The Hall recording is not the only documented instance in which Chinn appears to have secretly recorded a conversation. Through a separate Open Records Request submitted by Pipkins Reports, this publication obtained a city copy of a recorded interview between Michael Pipkins and Chinn concerning her involvement in the dismissal of former Fate Department of Public Safety Chief Lyle Lombard.
That recording also predates the controversy that would inevitably follow.
According to the records produced by the City of Fate, Chinn recorded that interview without disclosing it during the conversation. The existence of multiple recordings attributed to Chinn adds additional context to the current debate over undisclosed recordings by public officials and further raises questions about the consistency between her past actions and her more recent public criticism of the practice.
But according to the evidence reviewed by Pipkins Reports, Chinn appears to have engaged, multiple times, in the very conduct she later condemned.
Texas is a one-party consent state under state law, meaning only one participant in a conversation generally must consent to its recording. If Chinn initiated or participated in the call, recording it would not necessarily violate Texas law. The issue presented here is not primarily a legal one.
It is political.
Opinion
Politics has a funny way of exposing selective outrage.
For months, Fate residents have heard lectures from Codi Chinn about how secret recordings destroy trust, poison relationships, and undermine good government. Fair enough. Those are arguments reasonable people can debate.
But what legitimate purpose would have been gained by Chinn recording a conversation with the Former Mayor?
Given this revelation, it’s possible that the recordings by others that followed Chinn, may have been a defense mechanism (even unconsciously), over a situation that they could feel was off. Couple that with the deceptions that we now know were taking place by Chinn, and other council members, as well as the city manager, and it appears that there might have been a valid justification for both Greenberg and Hatley to take the actions that they did.
There’s another layer here which is important to understand as to why Pipkins Reports chose to clip this section of the audio. Chinn and Billings were not merely venting about Sen. Hall. They were criticizing an elected state senator over legislation affecting Fate, as well as Rockwall County in general, and discussing his approach to measures involving child safety in schools. Voters deserve to hear how public officials truly feel about those issues, and how they discuss those issues when they believe no one else is listening.
This recording doesn’t settle every argument currently consuming City Hall. It does, however, remove any illusion that only one side has participated in private recordings.
Sometimes the loudest critics leave behind the clearest evidence.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login